T. S. Eliot's Four Quartets in Spiritual Perspective
T. S. Eliot's Four Quartets in Spiritual Perspective
movement on the part of some visiting parties that are designated by the word we. The
visitors walk: Along the empty alley, into the box circle / To look down into the drained
pool.
The pool is quite dry and has been so for a long time. Nevertheless, the pool has the
illusion of being full. It is filled with water out of sunlight, and a lotus flower seems to
rise quietly out of the middle of it. The lotus gathers and arranges, in its extremely brief
and illusory existence, all the data surrounding it into itself. The sunlight shines like a
sudden and unmerited grace into the receptive pool, and causes the sacred lotus to rise up
at the same time. The poem mixes together a mystical vision with an actual or imagined
experience. The illusion is short-lived: Then a cloud passed and the pool was empty.
The pool is empty again. Is the emptiness here a reference to Buddhism in which
emptiness represents a numinous transparency that reveals the mystical core of all
experience? Let us regard the bowl as a container for dried rose petals and the pool as a
container for some dry rustling leaves. A shaft of sunlight descends upon the pool, and a
lotus flower arises in the poets dream or delusion. Might another shaft of dusty sunlight
have descended upon the bowl of roses as well?
The infusion of the sunbeam is necessary for the experience to take shape and to
gather together its influences and elements. There is more unheard music or laughter in
the shrubbery: Go, said the bird, for the leaves were full of children, / Hidden excitedly,
containing laughter.
In Buddhism, laughter is also a symptom of enlightenment. The hidden and higher
meaning of anything is to realize that it is empty, and that emptiness is bliss. The leaves
in their rustling are filled with the voices of children, suggesting the past and the children
who had lived in the house. Perhaps the visiting parties were once among the children
who laughed in that place long ago. The past is somehow still present. The birds message
anticipates the leaving of the guests and it decides that the event is completed.
Go, go, go, said the bird: human kind
Cannot bear very much reality.
Moments of epiphany and insight are rare for human beings, perhaps because they are
distractions from the workaday world in which we must live and function. This present
moment of memory and epiphany, answering to the birds call, is also a response to tunes
played long before, still hiding in the shrubbery or nestling in the leaves. Insofar as
anything is remembered, it is present. It is remembered as past, but it is gathered into a
present experience.
What might have been and what has been
Points to one end which is always present.
ii. Parts II to V of Burnt Norton
Part II of Burnt Norton starts with a verse about reconciliation and about some kind
of pattern. Reconciliation is needed for inveterate scars and for forgotten wars.
Reconciliation means healing, forgiveness, and the restoration of injured relationships.
Good patterns need to be repaired and rejuvenated. The movement in the circulation of
the blood is mirrored in the drift of stars. This pattern is repeated macrocosmically,
microcosmically, and in many places in between. There seems to be one well-coordinated
cosmic dance going on, involving stars and constellations.
There is patterned movement afoot, both high above and down below. But there is no
movement at the still point of the turning world. There is an undisturbed axis that threads
through the whirling vortex and welter of activity. The dance begins at the still point, but
here there is neither arrest nor movement, neither ascent nor decline. Except for the still
point, there is no dance, and there is only the dance. The still point is not in time and has
no movement, but it is the mysterious source of the dance and it is the attractive cause of
all movement.
What goes on here is the transformation of the temporal and the transient into the
eternal. Nothing of worth will be lost, but we cannot know this yet. To be conscious is not
to be completely in time; or rather, to be aware of time is to view time from the still point,
that is, from a point that is not in time, yet it is within all times.
The second verse of Part V, which is the poems final verse, says that love abides at
the still point and in eternity. God is love, although God is not mentioned as such. God
here is also Aristotles Unmoved Mover of the universe, who attracts all things to
Godself. Divine love is eternal, and is the source of all time, motion, and music. Ever
still, it moves things by attraction to itself. It is love unmoved and unmoving, love that
pulls all things toward itself as into their own fulfillment. It reveals itself at the end of the
poem, as it does at the poems very beginning, in a shaft of sunlight and in the laughter of
children. It does so in a momentary glimpse that provides the origin of the poem and
inspires the music that follows.
The four nowheres that are described in Four Quartets point at length to a still point,
that is, to a deep nowhere within the poet himself, to a gaping emptiness, which, in the
realization of its emptiness, receives as well the promise of a great fullness. Already
tasted, the coming fullness, which is eternal and in that sense is already here, takes away
the taste for finite accomplishments and enjoyments. There is an asceticism that
accompanies mysticism. Eliot tries to secularize a mysticism that can only be made
explicit by religious faith.
iii. Eliot, East Coker
East Coker is a village with family ties to Eliot, a middling kind of village, and hence
also a nowhere of sorts. The middle way Eliot refers to might also be the Dharma, or
teaching of Buddhism, the path midway between abnegation and self-indulgence, a way
discovered by persevering right effort, and yet, a way arrived at under the gentle force of
cosmic beneficence. This middle way is Keats' "negative capability at critical mass." It is
only known by living in uncertainty, by irony and paradox, by surmise, by "hints and
guesses." Here definiteness is the enemy of wisdom, and vagueness itself the only
certitude.
As the poem opens up and seems to compose itself, a seed of poetic creativity draws
into itself all the environmental influences that it needs for its own nourishment. Three
times, in Part I of the poem, an open field is mentioned. The ruminations in the poem
have to do with the passing away and clearing away of the things of the past, and about
whatever replaces them in the present. Among the possibilities for replacing the torn
down structures of the past is an open field. Leaving the field open exposes the bare
earth, and this poem is in ways a celebration of the bare earth. It has been pointed out that
the Four Quartets, one by one, carry the theme of ancient philosophy, that the four basic
elements are earth, air, fire, and water. East Coker is about earth.
Part I culminates in a dance at a wedding feast, a dance of ancient people who repeat
in their dance the patterns of seasons and constellations, and the rhythms of life in every
age. A great companion to the dance scene in East Coker is Thomas Mertons poetic
thoughts on the dance of the Lord in emptiness, which appear in the conclusion of New
Seeds of Contemplation. Merton presents the dance-like rhythms of the cosmos along the
lines of a dancing God, as in Hindu belief about the god Shiva.
The image of an open field in which dancers perform on the bare earth governs East
Coker. In East Coker, which is near Stonehenge, the ancient feast and pagan ceremonies
still hang in the air. It is as if a dance of an ancient, or possibly, a medieval people, and as
if during a wedding feast, were still going on. Thus the past is not felt as a heavy and
inescapable burden to be borne, but, the past is rather a barrage of joyful data to be taken
into ones present self and to be joined with in celebration. The basic emotional tone and
valuation of the poem is one of joy, although thepoem draws in non-joyful data as well
Part II of East Coker is about poetry. Poetry tries to follow the rhythms of the
constellations that whirl in a vortex that will one day bring an end to the world we know
in a destructive fire. In other words, life is fragile and temporary. Whether poetry
succeeds or not in capturing the rhythms and harmonizing with the music of the cosmos
does not matter greatly. The poem implies that the purpose of poetry is the achievement
of wisdom. If poetry aspires to the acquisition of wisdom, then the only wisdom is
humility. Perhaps it is implied that humility means standing in that open field, and
experiencing the wonder and excitement with which poetry always begins again.
When Eliot writes about Long hoped for calm, the autumnal serenity, he discovers
in his own terms that which Martin Heidegger describes in Discourse on Thinking as
and always will be there. The poem adds: the stillness [is ]the dancing. We must learn
how to be still and composed while participating in the dance. Contemplation and action
must accompany one another. There is a fine quality of mystical light that can only be
found in the darkness. The axis of inner stillness is found while we are active, moving,
and dancing. The stillness is in the dancing.
In the book, Redeeming Time: T. S. Eliotss Four Quartets, Kenneth Paul Kramer
suggests that the open field talked about by Eliot, and with that, Eliots ideas of emptiness
and darkness, have much to do with what the philosopher Martin Heidegger called
releasement. In Discourse on Thinking, Heidegger advocated an open-minded kind of
thinking that he called meditative thinking or poetic thinking. The word releasement
translates the German word Gelassenheit, which also means composure or calmness.
Heidegger derived his idea of Gelassenheit from the medieval mystic, Meister Eckhart.
A powerful image in East Coker is that of the wounded surgeon. The surgeon cuts
into the patient and cuts out whatever is diseased. Medical care sometimes causes pain or
discomfort in order to heal or cure the patient. The poet must deal with discomforting or
disturbing matters in order to bring some therapeutic relief, or indeed, just in order to be
honest about the real conditions and afflictions of human existence. Jesus was a suffering
servant and a wounded healed. And each of us, dealing with our own pain and hurts in
life, must extend ourselves toward others who are hurting. Kramer points out that East
Coker is Eliots meditation on a certain Good Friday.
In Part V, Eliot reaffirms the process perspective he assumes in East Coker. And so
each venture / Is a new beginning, a raid on the inarticulate. In reference to poetry
especially, it is true that each poem tries to express something that is either inexpressible,
or that simply has not yet been well expressed. Each new poem is a venture and an
adventure of ideas and words; each attempt at expression is a raid on the inarticulate
And, in spite of the passing away of all things, there is also the fight to recover what has
been lost, to save the expressions that have been considered successful.
vi. The Dry Salvages
The Dry Salvages is the name of a small group of rocks, with a beacon, off the north
east coast of Cape Ann, Massachusetts. The Dry Salvages is probably a corruption of the
French phrase, les trois sauvages, which means the three Indians. The word trois was
corrupted into dry. On the literal level, the phrase dry salvages is ironic, because the
islands are constantly washed by waves of the sea, and there is probably nothing to be
salvaged but a useless bit of memory. On the mystical level, these rocks represent a time
of spiritual aridity when unmerited saving grace washes redemptively over us.
The Dry Salvages begins as a poem about the natural music of the sea and about the
tolling of a sea buoy that is also called a groaner. The poem is also about time, and either
owes a debt to, or shares remarkable similarities with the philosophical treatment of time
in The Confessions of St. Augustine. In Four Quartets, time may be considered as a
transcendent principle that generates or radiates the flow of times as we know themor,
time may be considered as the ceaseless flow of ever perishing finite times For
Augustine, eternity is the timeless condition beyond all times that serves as the source of
ever flowing finite times.
As viewed philosophically by Augustine, time has several dimensions or layers of
meaning. First of all, there is cosmic time, which is the brute movement of natural
elements in rhythmic or regular patterns. The rotation of the earth on its axis gives us day
and night. The revolution of the earth around the sun gives us the solar year. Brute
unmeasured movements serve as the basis for our experience of time.
Secondly, there is chronological or measured time. The minutes of a clock divide the
hours of a day, which are arbitrarily set as divisions of the twenty-four hour duration of a
calendar day. The days of a year are enumerated at 365, as they divide the duration of the
time required for the earth to revolve about the sun. We experience our own lives as a
lapse of time in successive stages and with repeated patterns. It is the human mind that
measures times.
Thirdly, there are functional and cultural uses of time. There is a time to plant and a
time to reap. There are times for work and times for leisure; times for mourning, and
I do not know much about gods; but I think that the river
Is a strong, brown godsullen, untamed and intractable
.
Useful, trustworthy, as a conveyor of commerce.
The river is not viewed poetically; it is viewed as a resource to be exploited or an
obstacle to be surmounted. The dwellers in the cities generally forget about the river as
something natural, organic, and alive; they see it only from their own mechanical and
mercantile point of view. The poem takes the organic view that the rhythm of the river is
the same as the rhythm that beats in the breasts of human beings and in the circulation
that goes on in plants:
His rhythm was present in the nursery bedroom,
In the rank ailanthus of the April dooryard.
The Eliot family in the poets youth spent summers near Gloucester, Massachusetts. In
the second verse, which moves from St. Louis to a New England setting, the poets and
our relationship with both the river and the sea is recognized:
The river is within us, the sea is all about us;
The sea tosses its organic debris up onto the beaches:
Its hints of earlier and other creation:
The starfish, the hermit crab, the whales backbone;
And the sea tosses up cultural artifacts as well:
It tosses up our losses, the torn seine,
The shattered lobsterpot, the broken oar
The poem then mentions some of the many sounds or voices of the sea: the sea howl,
the sea yelp, the whine in the rigging. The rigging of the ship, while different from the
sea itself, picks up from the wind and from the ships motions the vibrations from the
pounding sea that the creaking rigging translates into sounds that we can hear.
Part II of The Dry Salvages laments the passing of time, as time brings loss and
destruction to all things. The withering and wailing of Part II share a similar doleful
tonality with the dryness and desiccation of Burnt Norton. While the sea as pictured
early in The Dry Salvages, has many sounds and voices, the later wailing over death
and decay is silent:
Where is there an end of it, the soundless wailing,
The silent withering of autumn flowers
Dropping their petals and remaining motionless
Where is there an end to the drifting wreckage,
The prayer of the bone on the beach, the unprayable
Prayer at the calamitous annunciation?
The calamitous annunciation is the message of the bell that clangs from the buoy near
the savage rocks. It is a tolling that reminds of death and its immediate danger.
The silent listening to the undeniable
Clamour of the bell of the last annunciation.
The last annunciation is death, and its clamor is undeniable. Death is inevitable; it
must be accepted that life is brief and fleeting. The signs of death are everywhere. The
wreckage of ships and lost lives fills the sea and washes up on beaches. Whitehead deals
with the deaths of all things, that is, the deaths of all actual entities, in his doctrine of
perpetual perishing. Accordingly, all these atomic specks of life pass away as soon as
they come into being. Death is everywhere constant and immediate, yet value is
preserved and passed on.
The bones prayer to death its God. Only the hardly, barely prayable
Prayer of the one Annunciation.
This is the point in the poem, and indeed in Four Quartets, when poetry becomes
prayer. This time the word Annunciation is spelled with a capital A. It refers here to the
response of the Blessed Mother to the angel Gabriel: Be it done unto me according to
your word. We have nothing to do but accept and acquiesce in the face of death. Prayer
has first to do with adoring receptivity toward divine influence, and only secondarily with
making supplications. The poem says that death is the bones God. The bone says a
prayer to Death, and therefore must have a hope for something that only death can
supply.
The way that, for Whitehead, value is preserved and passed on, is through the dynamic
of prehension. This happens especially in relation to what he calls the consequent nature
of God. The consequent nature is the aspect of God that absorbs and preserves all the
achieved perfection of the world. It salvages what is still valuable from the debris of our
lives. While actual entities pass away, they register as permanent effects in the allembracing and saving divine consequent nature. The consequent nature of God is
Whiteheads heaven and his version of the Kingdom of God. Gods inner life and
consequent nature salvage all that is worth saving.
A recurring message in Four Quartets is that in the end is the beginning, or even that,
in my end is my beginning. Similarly, for Whitehead, God processes the contents of
Gods consequent nature in such a way as to feed back into the world a hoard of
suggestions and possibilities for the next generation of successor actual entities. While for
Whitehead, past and prehended actual entities lack the subjectivity and mentality that
they formerly possessed, we may choose better to think that, in the ultimate divine
embrace, subjective thought and feeling are restored.
Contemplating the agony of countless persons over the seemingly endless ages, and
having said that agony abides, the poem says:
Time the destroyer is time the preserver.
The sea, like the universe, is a great destroyer of what it first created and nourished.
Although unfathomable and incomprehensible, death is a condition that must be
accepted. The poem invokes the name of the Hindu God Krishna, who is an avatar of
Vishnu. To a Christian, an avatar suggests the idea of incarnation; that is, the god takes on
the aspect of a human being. To a Christian, the idea of incarnation is closely connected,
not only to death, but to resurrection. Krishna is a warrior and savior. Vishnu is a
preserver of live. In the cases of both Christ and of Krishna, death is something we pass
through to new and better life.
ix. Parts II and III of The Dry Salvages
In reference to the certain eventual perishing of all things, there are lines in Part II of
The Dry Salvages that are quite amenable and helpful to a Whiteheadian perspective.
The doctrine of perpetual perishing is supported by the lines of the poem. In reference to
a journey on a train, the poem reads:
You are not the same people who left that station
Or who will arrive at any terminus,
In a radically process perspective, it is a brand new universe in every new instant. In
important ways, we are new persons in every new moment of our lives. Whiteheads
principle of creativity reigns supreme, and, creativity is a principle of novelty. Creativity
is not the principle of order and design, for Whitehead; God is the principle of order and
design. For him, creativity plans nothing; it simply serves as the energy by which any and
all events occur. This is why I say that God is anonymously the real ultimate in
Whiteheads thought.
The poem also says:
And the time of death is every moment
Which shall fructify in the lives of others:
And do not think of the fruit of action.
Fare forward.
When the poem says Fare forward, it honors the anticipation phase of the actual
entity. It also favors the decision phase, as it sets a resolution with determination to face
the future. The future means death, but it also means all that shall happen to us and all
that we shall do before we die.
The actual entities experienced or prehended while reading The Dry Salvages have
within them many enriching contrasts. These contrasts would include: wet and dry,
Mississippi River and Atlantic Ocean, devotional piety and mysticism, silence and
sounds, commercial and poetic perspectives, Krishna and Christ, saints and ordinary
people, human and divine (as in incarnation), danger and protection, elapsing time and
timeless eternity. The balance of these contrasts brings excitement to the poem, and
allows the unity in a highly diverse set of experiences to be felt in a culminating
satisfaction.
In the poem, Mary is honored as the greatest of all saints, because in her body the
incarnation of the divine in the human takes place. The incarnation takes place, not as an
event that transpired many centuries ago, but rather as one that, viewed as from eternity,
takes place right now in the radical present. The incarnation is the point of intersection of
the timeless with time. Through this prayer and this realization, the mariner belongs to
Mary, and so receives the most powerful protection that is anywhere available.
The poems Burnt Norton and The Dry Salvages complement one another, as they
comprise half of the rich poetic sequence named Four Quartets. These two poems can be
used to help understand and to interpret one another. The shaft of sunlight and the still
point in the turning world that is present in Burnt Norton is a key to understanding
The Dry Salvages, and, indeed, all Four Quartets. Even so, the ideas of annunciation
and incarnation in The Dry Salvages throw beacons of light upon Burnt Norton and
upon all Four Quartets.
iv. Little Gidding
Historically, Little Gidding is a place associated with the Anglican monk Nicholas
Ferrar, and with King Charles I, who was pursued there by the Puritan army under
Cromwell, captured, and later beheaded. In the Anglican Church, King Charles I is
considered to be a martyr. Large in the motivation of the blood-thirsty Cromwell was the
reform of the Church of England according to Puritan and Calvinist principles. A
community of Anglican monks lived a spiritual life near Little Gidding in an open field
near a pigsty. A renovated version of the chapel they first built near that place exists even
today.
Little Gidding stands on it own as an important poem, and it is also the culmination
of Four Quartets. The poem is arranged in five parts or movements, as would occur in a
musical composition. The ending lines of the poem assure us that All shall be well. The
fire of purgation and the heavenly rose shall be made one. Some lines adapted from the
writing of Julianna of Norwich bespeak the goal and purpose of Four Quartets. Indeed,
this poem is about the purpose of life and of all that we do; it is also about the purpose of
poetry, language, and the power of words.
Little Gidding is about the Holy Spirit, about the flames above the heads of the
disciples on Pentecost, and about the tongues of fire that came on Pentecost Day. The
poem is about martyrdom, history, and the meaning of suffering in this life. For Eliot, this
life is about learning how to suffer well, how to find meaning in suffering. Four Quartets
is a poetic masterpiece, and it is also an important contribution to theology. Eliots
theology is a theology of the cross, although I do not think he mentions the cross in Four
Quartets.
The converging tongues of fire, the fires of purgation and perpetual perishing, will
coalesce into the shape of a rose. It is an eternal mystical fire, representing not
destruction, but everlasting preservation in the bliss of glory. Ultimately these poems are
about spirituality, mysticism, mature faith, authentic death, and the kind of hope a
modern person may have. It is fitting, if not required, that the truth, wisdom, and message
of the gospel and of Pentecost be spread by means of poetry that aspires to the condition
of music.
As a feast of the church, Pentecost is about language, communication, contemplation,
and poetry. It is about the deep connection between the outward mission of the church
and the inward contemplation of the mystery of life in this world. Somehow, the idea of
Pentecostal fire connects the outgoing enthusiasm of the churchs mission with the inner
sorrow that is part of mystical growth and spiritual maturity. For Eliot, poetry has
everything to do with the improvement and purification of language, and Pentecost is the
feast that celebrates language.
There are some interesting lines and thoughts about purpose in Part I of Little
Gidding. Some lines read: . . .Either you had no purpose / Or the purpose is beyond
the end you figured / And is altered in fulfillment. Having no purpose, I would assume,
means having no purpose other than just going there to see the place out of idle curiosity.
One can never act without having some purpose in mind. Visiting Little Gidding would
entail wanting to see the place, to visit some people there, or to go there on a spiritual
pilgrimage. Of course, one could intend only to drive by it on the way to some other
place, and have ones can break down, and stay while the car is being fixed. In the last
case we might say we have no purpose in being there.
As we perform any work or work on any project, we may discover that our real
purpose is beyond or different than our purpose as originally conceived. As we complete
any project, we may realize that our purpose in doing it has changed along the way. The
philosopher Whitehead thinks of purpose as an aim given to us in each moment of time,
which aim we then adjust in the moment into an aim of our own. For him, in every new
moment there is a new aim given, and a new adjustment according to our own free
subjectivity. For example, I may go to the kitchen in order to prepare a cup of tea, and
then stay there to wash up the breakfast dishes, forgetting to prepare the tea.
Eliots point in discussing purpose here is to ask why anyone would want to go to
Little Gidding at any time or under any circumstances. It is after all a nowhere, a place at
the end of the earth, so to speak. Is there a play on words here? The poem says that Little
Gidding is a place at the worlds end, so then, what aim, end, or purpose would anyone
have in coming here? The purpose one would have in coming here is much unlike the
purpose one would have in going anywhere else. Ironically, there must be a special
reason or purpose for coming to a place that is a nowhere.
Eventually, the poem tells what the purpose of a visit to Little Gidding is. The poem
tells us what its own purpose is, as well as what the purpose of anyones visit to Little
Gidding might be. You are here to kneel / Where prayer has been valid, says the poem.
Kneeling implies adoration, and adoration implies focusing ones attention on God. In
real prayer, the focus is not on the suppliant and his or her wants and needs. The focus is
on God, and the attitude is one of trust in God, to the point of resigning ones will to
Gods will. Such prayer is always valid, and the prayer of King Charles I, a valid and
saintly prayer, resounds there still in eloquent silence.
In the background of the poem is a question about the essence of history. History is
about the past, but history concerns the present. When one visits a shrine, one communes
with the saint who abides in that sacred place. In the poem the poet meets his own ghost,
and so the present poet takes a walk and has a conversation with his future self, a dead
self, but a dead self who has passed through death to a greater awareness. The poet owes
history his own attempt at success in the effort to improve language and culture, to purify
the dialect of the tribe, so to speak. This effort requires passing through a purifying fire.
Having taught his lesson, the ghost blesses his former self and then leaves.
In Part IV of the poem, the Holy Spirit descends as Pentecostal fire. It is the
inspiration of the Holy Spirit that inspires the poet, purifies his tongue and spirit, so that
the poet may speak and write what is required. Biblical inspiration was once required to
insure that the biblical books were written, and that they were worthy to be interpreted as
works of divinity itself. In the modern world, poets still require pentecostal fire in order
for secular language and culture to be appropriately directed. Pentecostal fire appears first
of all in tongues, establishing its connection to the sacred word and to secular poetry.
Poetry that is true and real may appear as secular, but its origin and inspiration are sacred.
This is Eliots theology.
Near the end the poem says: We shall not cease from exploration. The journey goes
on, requiring many adaptations, translations, and interpretations. In the end, we return to
our beginning, once again, as if for the very first time. What is new will always be new,
because it always was new. It is eternity, an eternity that is not tired from its embodiment
in time and from times endless repetitions, but one that is always amazed at its own
freshness. Burned away with the chaff of futile history and idle time is the delusion that
eternity can be adequately glimpsed by eyes that are timely and secular. We await
eternitys full manifestation of itself, not yet having the eyes to see it.