DEVENDRA W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

E.O P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB QUEST NO/
REPORT Chargesheet PARAB Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE PAG NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT Particular

8/ 225 50/42 NOT IN NOT IN 17,18/130 Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who is
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 36/284 114/81
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ. SERVICE SERVICE 70/142 witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

51,52,53/
37/286 109 NOT IN 17,18/130 Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh Morkar was
2 27.06.2013 P Y P 38/287 115/82 75,76/113 SERVICE 70/142 on 3 rd Shift

51,52,53/
39/288 109 NOT IN 17,18/130
3 15.07.2013 P Y P 132/670 116/82 75,76/113 SERVICE 70/142 Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar weekly off

51,52,53/
109 NOT IN 17,18/130
4 23.07.2013 P Y P 40/290 117/82 75,76/113 SERVICE 70/142 Morkar weekly off

51,52,53/
109 NOT IN 17,18/130
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291 118/82 75,76/113 SERVICE 70/142
17,18/130
70/142
42/292 51,52,53/ 31/131 70 1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off. 2.
43/293 109 NOT IN to Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent by
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 44/294 119/82 75,76/113 SERVICE 80/142,143 Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry

NOT IN 70 to
7 08.02.2014 WO NO WO 42/292 120/83 SERVICE 80/142,143 All AW weekly off Saturday

45/296 NOT IN 17,18/130 This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty not
8 14.03.2014 P NO A 132/670 121/83 SERVICE 7/142 produce in enquiry

This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and

46/298 NOT IN 17,18/130 meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
MAIL 9.50 AM H.O 9 24.03.2014 UO NO A 67/380 122/83 SERVICE 7/142 ( jogeshwari) incident .

Morkar is in II shift and also present in thane.

04.07.2014 124/83
16.07.2014 125/84
51 ,52 ,53
/109 17,18/130
54/110 70 to
MITING IN 2.30 74/142 75 ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi Nadkarni
PM IN H.O( W- 51/42 51 , 54 , 75 ,76 NOT IN 16/6/2014 to 80/143 and Sawargaonkar are witnessess and not present
MANOJ )NOT 123/83 58 ,61 62 /113 SERVICE JOINING 132/670 31/131 in enquiry.

10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014 JUN 2013 TO JUN 2014

51,52,53/
173 to 109
178/95,96 PRESENTI SHEET NOT
75,76/113 17,18/130
112,114/81 PRODUES IN ENQ 51/351 67/112 70/142

E.O i 22.04.2014 UO Y A ****

Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not produce
Presenty
51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
178/95,96 PRESENTI SHEET NOT
75,76/113 17,18/130
112,114/81 PRODUES IN ENQ 54/355 68/112 70/142

E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P *****

Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is witness and
not present in enquiry.

51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
178/95,96 PRESENTI SHEET NOT
75,76/113 17,18/130
112,114/81 PRODUES IN ENQ 58/362 69/112 70/142

E.O iii 26.05.2014 UO Y A ****

Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile is
Union off and Kardiles name mentioned in mail

51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
178/95,96 PRESENTI SHEET NOT
75,76/113 17,18/130
112,114/81 PRODUES IN ENQ 61/370 70/112 70/142

E.O iv 24.02.2014 UO Y A *****

51/42
179/96
180,181/97
Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our names
are not mentioned.
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
178/95,96 PRESENTI SHEET NOT
75,76/113 17,18/130 Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty
112,114/81 PRODUES IN ENQ 62/371 71/112 70/142

E .O v 28.05.2014 UO Y A ****
mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not present
in enquiry
51/42 59/368 ,67/ 51,52,53/
179/96 380 ,11/231 109 11/231 ,12
180,181/97 ,12/233 ,19/ 54/110 NOT IN PRESENTI SHEET NOT
/233 ,19/2 17,18/130
124/83 241 71/112 SERVICE PRODUES IN ENQ 41 70/142

59/368
67/380

H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO NO A 11/231

12/233
19/241
125/83,84
51,52,53/
109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
70,71,72/14
2
incident happened with technicial director and
Senior director HR and both are not present in
enquiry
PRODUES IN ENQ

finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

12 51,52,53/ Kanitakr are saying that this incident happened
E.O pag no 97 P.KANITK 59/368 109 73 TO with them in their cabin and Kanitakar sitting in
(16/jun/2014) AR 16.07.2014 P P.Y ABSENT 132/670 54/110
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ 80/142.143 Thane as well as Suman sitting in Ho

NO CHARG
IN 51,52,53/
12-A CHARGSHEE 109 NOT IN Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same incident
EXH 59/13 S.KUMAR 16.07.2014 P Y 132/670 T 54/110 SERVICE he and Kanitakr telling happened with them.

13 17.07.2014 P **** A ***** NO CHARG IN CHARGSHEET

86,87/50
106
TO
109/54 /53

112,113/81
128 /86
129 /87
173 TO 1/117
175/95
179 TO 54/110 2 ,4 /118
182/96,97 17,18/130
184,185,186 75 ,76 1 ST DAY IN 17/121 PRESENTI SHEET NOT
70 TO
/98 /113 THANE PLANT 131/669 20/122 PRODUES IN ENQ 80/142,143
E .O
EXH :65(
1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 48/304
63/374
Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan writtent
this mail and not present in enquiry
MAHENDRA W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no QUEST
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB NO/ PAG
E.O REPORT Chargsheet MMU Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT Particular

8/ 225 50/41 NOT IN NOT IN 17,18/13 Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 36/284 114/77
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ. SERVICE SERVICE 0 70/142 is witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

51,52,53/
37/286 109 NOT IN 17,18/13 Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh
2 27.06.2013 P Y P 38/287 115/78 75,76/113 SERVICE 0 70/142 Morkar was on 3 rd Shift

51,52,53/
39/288 109 NOT IN 17,18/13 Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar
3 15.07.2013 P Y P 132/670 116/78 75,76/113 SERVICE 0 70/142 weekly off

51,52,53/
109 NOT IN 17,18/13
4 23.07.2013 P Y P 40/290 117/78 75,76/113 SERVICE 0 70/142 Morkar weekly off

51,52,53/
109 NOT IN 17,18/13
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291 118/78 75,76/113 SERVICE 0 70/142
17,18/13
0 70/142
31/131
42/292 51,52,53/ 70 to 1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off.
43/293 109 NOT IN 80/142,1 2. Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 44/294 119/78 75,76/113 SERVICE 43 by Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry

70 to
NOT IN 80/142,1
7 08.02.2014 WO NO WO 42/292 120/79 SERVICE 43 All AW weekly off Saturday

45/296 NOT IN 17,18/13 This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty
8 14.03.2014 UO NO A 132/670 121/79 SERVICE 0 7/142 not produce in enquiry

P 46/298 NOT IN 17,18/13

This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and
meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
MAIL 9.50 AM H.O 9 24.03.2014 (Thane) NO A 67/380 122/83 SERVICE 0 7/142 ( jogeshwari) incident .
Morkar is in II shift and also present in
thane.

MMU present in thane plant.

MITING IN 2.30 ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi

PM IN H.O( W- Nadkarni and Sawargaonkar are witnessess
MANOJ )NOT 124,125/83 and not present in enquiry.

51 ,52 ,53 17,18/13

/109 0 70 to
54/110 74/142
75 to
51/42 51 , 54 , 75 ,76 NOT IN 16/6/2014 80/143
10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014 123/83 58 ,61 62 /113 SERVICE JOINING 132/670 31/131

51,52,53/
173 to 109
E.O i 22.04.2014 PL Y A ****
178/95,96
51/42
112,114/81
179/96
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 51/351
75,76/113
67/112
17,18/13 Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not
0 70/142 produce Presenty
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P *****
178/95,96
51/42
112,114/81
179/96
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 54/355
75,76/113
68/112
17,18/13
0 70/142
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is
witness and not present in enquiry.
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109 Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile
E.O iii 26.05.2014 P Y A ****
178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 58/362
75,76/113
69/112
17,18/13 is Union off and Kardiles name mentioned
0 70/142 in mail
51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E.O iv 24.02.2014 P Y A *****
178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 61/370
75,76/113
70/112
17,18/13
0 70/142
Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our
names are not mentioned.

51/42 Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty

179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E .O v 28.05.2014 P Y A ****
178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 62/371
75,76/113
71/112
17,18/13 mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not
0 70/142 present in enquiry

59/368
67/380 51/42 59/368 ,67/ 51,52,53/
11/231 179/96 380 ,11/231 109 11/231 ,12 incident happened with technicial director
H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO NO A 12/233
19/241
180,181/97
124/83
,12/233 ,19/ 54/110
241 71/112
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
/233 ,19/2 17,18/13 and Senior director HR and both are not
41 0 70/142 present in enquiry

finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

Kanitakr are saying that this incident
12 51,52,53/ happened with them in their cabin and
P.KANITK
E.O pag no 97
(16/jun/2014) AR 16.07.2014 P P.Y ABSENT
59/368
132/670 125/83,84
109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
70,71,72/ Kanitakar sitting in Thane as well as Suman
142 sitting in Ho

51,52,53/ 73 TO Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same

12-A
EXH 59/132 S.KUMAR 16.07.2014 P P.Y
S.KUMAR PRESENTI
SHEET NOT IN PRODUES
ON ENQ 132/670
109
54/110
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
80/142.1 incident he and Kanitakr telling happened
43 with them.

NO CHARG

13 17.07.2014 **** ****

A *****
IN
CHARGSHEE
T
51,52,53/
109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE NO CHARG IN CHARGSHEET

86,87/50
106
TO
109/54 /53

112,113/81
128 /86
129 /87
173 TO 1/117
175/95
179 TO 54/110 2 ,4 /118 17,18/13
E .O 182/96,97 0 70 TO Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan
1 ST DAY IN
EXH :65(1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 48/304
63/374
184,185,186
/98
75 ,76
/113 THANE PLANT 131/669
17/121
20/122
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
80/142,1
43
writtent this mail and not present in
enquiry
DEVENDRA W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

E.O P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB QUEST NO/
REPORT Chargesheet PARAB Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE PAG NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT Particular

106,107,108 17 ,18/130
8/ 225 /54 NOT IN NOT IN Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who is
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 36/284 112,113/81
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ. ***** SERVICE **** **** SERVICE ***** 70/142 witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

106 , 107, 51/109

108 / 54 52/109
112,113/81 53/109 17 ,18/130
37/286 75/113 NOT IN Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh Morkar was
2 27.06.2013 P Y P 38/287 115/82 (-----''----) ****** 76/113 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 on 3 rd Shift

106,107, 51/109
108/ 54 52/109
112,113 53/109 17 ,18/130
39/288 /81 75/113 NOT IN
3 15.07.2013 P Y P 132/670 116 / 82 (-----''----) ******* 76/113 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar weekly off

106,107, 51/109
108/54 52/109
112,113 /81 53/109 17 ,18/130
75/113 NOT IN
4 23.07.2013 P Y P 40/290 116/82 (-----''----) ****** 76/113 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 Morkar weekly off

106,107,108 51/109
/ 54 52/109
112,113/81 53/109 17 ,18/130
75/113 NOT IN
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291 118/82 (-----''----) ******* 76/113 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142

106,107,108 51/109
/ 54 52/109
42/292 112,113/81 53/109 17 ,18/130 1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off. 2.
43/293 75/113 NOT IN Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent by
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 44/294 119/82 (-----''----) ******* 76/113 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry
70 TO 80
NOT IN Page
7 08.02.2014 WO NO WO 42/292 120/83 (-----''----) ****** ****** SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** no.142,143 All AW weekly off Saturday

17 ,18/130
45/296 NOT IN This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty not
8 14.03.2014 P NO A 132/670 121/83 (-----''----) ******* ****** SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 produce in enquiry

17 ,18/130 This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and

46/298 NOT IN meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
MAIL 9.50 AM H.O 9 24.03.2014 UO NO A 67/380 122/83 (-----''----) ******* ***** SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 ( jogeshwari) incident .

Morkar is in II shift and also present in thane.

04.07.2014 124/83
16.07.2014 125/84

MITING IN 2.30 ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi Nadkarni

PM IN H.O( W- and Sawargaonkar are witnessess and not present
MANOJ )NOT in enquiry.

51 ,52 ,53
/109
54/110 17,18/130
70 to
10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014
51/42
123/83 (-----''----)
51 , 54 ,
58 ,61 62
75 ,76
/113
NOT IN
SERVICE **** ****
16/6/2014
JOINING 132/670
74/142 75
to 80/143 JUN 2013 TO JUN 2014

51 ,53
E.O i 22.04.2014 UO Y A **** *****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 51/351
/109
67/112 (-----''----) **** **** *****
17,18/130
70/142
Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not produce
Presenty

51/42
179/96
180,181/ 97
E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P ***** 123/83
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 54/355
51 ,53/10
9 68/112 (-----''----) **** **** *****
17,18/130
70/142
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is witness and
not present in enquiry.

51/42
179/96 180,
E.O iii 26.05.2014 UO Y A ****
181 / 97
123/83
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 58/362
51 ,53/10
9 69/112 (-----''----) **** **** ****
17,18/130
70/142
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile is
Union off and Kardiles name mentioned in mail
51/42
179/96
180,181 /97
E.O iv 24.02.2014 UO Y A ***** 123/83
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 61/370
51 ,53/10
9 70/112 (-----''----) **** **** ****
17,18/130
70/142
Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our names
are not mentioned.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty

51/42
179/96
180,181 /97 51/109
E .O v 28.05.2014 UO Y A **** 123/83
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 62/371
53/109
71/112 (-----''----) **** **** *****
17,18/130
70/142
mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not present
in enquiry

59/368
67/380 59/368 ,67/

H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO NO A 11/231

12/233
19/241 124/83,84 (-----''----)
380 ,11/231
,12/233 ,19/
241
51/109
53/109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE **** ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
11/231 ,12
/233 ,19/2
41
70 , 71 ,
72 /142
incident happened with technicial director and
Senior director HR and both are not present in
enquiry

73 TO 80 finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

12 51/109 Kanitakr are saying that this incident happened
E.O pag no 97 P.KANITK 59/368 53/109 NOT IN Page no. 142 with them in their cabin and Kanitakar sitting in
(16/jun/2014) AR 16.07.2014 P P.Y ABSENT 132/670 125/84 (-----''----) ****** 54/110 SERVICE **** ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ , 143 Thane as well as Suman sitting in Ho

73 TO 80
12-A Page no. 142 Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same incident
EXH 59/13 S.KUMAR 16.07.2014 P Y 132/670 ******
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ , 143 he and Kanitakr telling happened with them.

NO CHARG

13 17.07.2014 P **** A *****

IN
CHARGSHEE
T (-----''----) ******
NOT IN
SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) NO CHARG IN CHARGSHEET
86,87 / 50
106,
107,108,109
/54
112,113/81
128/86
129/87
173,174,175
/95 179 1/117
E .O TO
182/96,97
1/117
2,4/118 2 ,4 /118 17,18/130
EXH :65( 17/121 54/110 70 TO
120,121/122 75/113 1 ST DAY IN
1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 48/304
63/374
184,185,186
/98 (-----''----) 76/113 THANE PLANT 131/669
17/121
20/122
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
80/142,143 Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan writtent
this mail and not present in enquiry
MAHENDRA W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no QUEST
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB NO/ PAG
E.O REPORT Chargsheet MMU Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT Particular

(50/41 ,54/
8/ 225 43, 60/44 ) NOT IN NOT IN Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 36/284 114/77
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ. ***** SERVICE **** **** SERVICE ***** 70/142 is witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

51 ,52 ,53
/107
54/108
(50/41 ,54/
37/286 43 , 60/44 ) 75 ,76 NOT IN Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh
2 27.06.2013 P Y P 38/287 115/78 (-----''----) ****** /111 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 Morkar was on 3 rd Shift

51 ,52 ,53
/107
54/108
(50/41 ,54/
39/288 43, 60/44 ) 75 ,76 NOT IN Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar
3 15.07.2013 P Y P 132/670 116/78 (-----''----) ******* /111 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 weekly off

51 ,52 ,53
/107
54/108
(50/41 ,54/
43, 60/44 ) 75 ,76 NOT IN
4 23.07.2013 P Y P 40/290 117/78 (-----''----) ****** /111 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 Morkar weekly off

51 ,52 ,53
/107
54/108
(50/41 ,54/
43, 60/44 ) 75 ,76 NOT IN
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291 118/78 (-----''----) ******* /111 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142

51 ,52 ,53
/107
54/108
42/292 (50/41 ,54/ 1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off.
43/293 43 ,60/44 ) 75 ,76 NOT IN 2. Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 44/294 119/78 (-----''----) ******* /111 SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 by Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry
NOT IN
7 08.02.2014 WO NO WO 42/292 120/79 (-----''----) ****** ****** SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 All AW weekly off Saturday

45/296 NOT IN This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty

8 14.03.2014 UO NO A 132/670 121/79 (-----''----) ******* ****** SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 not produce in enquiry

P 46/298 NOT IN
This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and
meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
MAIL 9.50 AM H.O 9 24.03.2014 (Thane) NO A 67/380 122/79 (-----''----) ******* ***** SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) **** 70/142 ( jogeshwari) incident .
Morkar is in II shift and also present in
thane.

MMU present in thane plant.

MITING IN 2.30 ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi

PM IN H.O( W- Nadkarni and Sawargaonkar are witnessess
MANOJ )NOT and not present in enquiry.
51 ,52 ,53
/107
54/108

51/41 ,123 51 , 54 , 75 ,76 NOT IN 16/6/2014

10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014 /79 (-----''----) 58 ,61 62 /111 SERVICE **** **** JOINING 132/670 70/142

51 ,53
E.O i 22.04.2014 PL Y A **** *****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 51/351
/107
67/110 (-----''----) **** **** ***** 70/142
Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not
produce Presenty

E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P ***** ****

PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 54/355
51 ,53/10
7 68/110 (-----''----) **** **** ***** 70/142
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is
witness and not present in enquiry.

Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile

E.O iii 26.05.2014 P Y A **** ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 58/362
51 ,53/10
7 69/110 (-----''----) **** **** **** 70/142
is Union off and Kardiles name mentioned
in mail

E.O iv 24.02.2014 P Y A ***** ****

PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 61/370
51 ,53/10
7 70/110 (-----''----) **** **** **** 70/142
Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our
names are not mentioned.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty

E .O v 28.05.2014 P Y A **** ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 62/371
51 ,53/10
7 71/110 (-----''----) **** **** ***** 70/142
mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not
present in enquiry

59/368
67/380 59/368 ,67/
11/231 380 ,11/231 51 ,53 11/231 ,12 incident happened with technicial director
H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO NO A 12/233
19/241 124/79,80 (-----''----)
,12/233 ,19/
241
/107
54/108
NOT IN
SERVICE **** ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
/233 ,19/2 71 ,72 ,73 and Senior director HR and both are not
41 ,74 /142 present in enquiry

finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

Kanitakr are saying that this incident
12 51 ,53 happened with them in their cabin and
P.KANITK
E.O pag no 97
(16/jun/2014) AR 16.07.2014 P P.Y ABSENT
59/368
132/670 125/80 (-----''----) ******
/107
54/108
NOT IN
SERVICE **** ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
Kanitakar sitting in Thane as well as Suman
sitting in Ho

Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same

12-A
EXH 59/132 S.KUMAR 16.07.2014 P P.Y
S.KUMAR PRESENTI
SHEET NOT IN PRODUES
ON ENQ 132/670 ******
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
incident he and Kanitakr telling happened
with them.

NO CHARG

13 17.07.2014 **** ****

A *****
IN
CHARGSHEE
T (-----''----) ******
51 ,53
/107
54/108
NOT IN
SERVICE **** **** (-----''----) NO CHARG IN CHARGSHEET

86/49
87/49
106
107 108,
109 /53
110 111 /
75
128 /84 1/117
129 /85
173 174 54/108 2 ,4 /118
E .O 175/93 180 Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan
1 ST DAY IN
EXH :65(1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 48/304
63/374
182/95
184/96 (-----''----)
75 ,76
/111 THANE PLANT 131/669
17/121
20/122
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
writtent this mail and not present in
enquiry
TAWDE W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

E.O P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no QUEST
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB NO/ PAG
REPORT Chargsheet TAWDE Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT Particular

106,107,108
/53
8/ 225 112,113,114 NOT IN NOT IN 17,18/12 Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 36/284 /79
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ. SERVICE SERVICE 8 70/140 is witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

106,107,108
/53 51,52,53/
2 27.06.2013 UO NO P
37/286
38/287
112,113,115
/79
107
75,76/111
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/12
8 70/140
Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh
Morkar was on 3 rd Shift

106,107,108
/53 51,52,53/
39/288 112,113,116 107 NOT IN 17,18/12 Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar
3 15.07.2013 P Y P 132/670 /79 75,76/111 SERVICE 8 70/140 weekly off

106,107,108
/53 51,52,53/
112,113,117 107 NOT IN 17,18/12
4 23.07.2013 P Y P 40/290 /79 75,76/111 SERVICE 8 70/140 Morkar weekly off

106,107,108
/53 51,52,53/
112,113,118 107 NOT IN 17,18/12
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291 /80 75,76/111 SERVICE 8 70/140

106,107,108
42/292 /53 51,52,53/ 1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off.
43/293 112,113,119 107 NOT IN 17,18/12 2. Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 44/294 /80 75,76/111 SERVICE 8 70/140 by Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry
NOT IN 70 to
7 08.02.2014 WO NO WO 42/292 120/81 SERVICE 80/140 All AW weekly off Saturday

17,18/12
45/296 NOT IN 870 to This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty
E.O 8 14.03.2014 P Y A 132/670 121/81 SERVICE 80/140 not produce in enquiry

This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and

46/298
MAIL 9.50 AM H.O 9 24.03.2014
P
(Thane) NO A 67/380 122/81
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/12
8 70/140
meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
( jogeshwari) incident .
Morkar is in II shift and also present in
thane.

MMU present in thane plant.

MITING IN 2.30 PM ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi

IN H.O( W- Nadkarni and Sawargaonkar are witnessess
MANOJ )NOT 124,125/83 and not present in enquiry.
51 to
54/107 17,18/12
8 70 to
51/41 51 , 54 , 75 ,76 NOT IN 16/6/2014 75/140
10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014 123/81 58 ,61 62 /117 SERVICE JOINING 132/670 31/129

51,52,53/
173 to 107 17,18/12
E.O i 22.04.2014 P Y A 178/92
112,114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 51/351
75,76/113
67/110
8 70/140 Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not
31/129 produce Presenty

51/41 179
to 181/93 51,52,53/
123/81 173 107 17,18/12
E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P to 178/92
112,114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 54/355
75,76/113
68/110
8 70/140
31/129
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is
witness and not present in enquiry.
51/41 179
to 181/93 51,52,53/
123/81 173 107 17,18/12 Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile
E.O iii 26.05.2014 P Y A to 178/92
112,114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 58/362
75,76/113
69/110
8 70/140 is Union off and Kardiles name mentioned
31/129 in mail

179 to
181/93 173 51,52,53/
to 178/92 107 17,18/12
E.O iv 24.02.2014 P Y A 112
to114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 61/370
75,76/113
70/110
8 70/140
31/129
Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our
names are not mentioned.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty

51/41 179
to 181/93 51,52,53/
123/81 173 107 17,18/12
E .O v 28.05.2014 P Y A ****
to 178/92
112,114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 62/371
75,76/113
71/110
8 70/140 mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not
31/129 present in enquiry

51/41 179
59/368 to 181/93
67/380 123/81 173 59/368 ,67/ 51,52,53/ 17,18/12
11/231 to 178/92 380 ,11/231 107 11/231 ,12 8 70 to incident happened with technicial director
E .O H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO Y A 12/233
19/241
112,114/79
124/81
,12/233 ,19/ 75,76/113
241 72/111
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
/233 ,19/2 72/140
41 31/129
and Senior director HR and both are not
present in enquiry

finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

51,52,53/ Kanitakr are saying that this incident
12 107 happened with them in their cabin and
E.O
P.KANITK
AR 16.07.2014 P P.Y ABSENT
59/368
132/670 125/82
75,76/113
72/108
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
70,71,72/ Kanitakar sitting in Thane as well as Suman
140 sitting in Ho
51,52,53,5
12-A 4/107 Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same
EXH 59/132
S.KUMA
R 16.07.2014 P P.Y 132/670
75,76/113
72/111
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
73 TO
80/140
incident he and Kanitakr telling happened
with them.

NO CHARG
IN 51,52,53/
13 17.07.2014 P NO A *****
CHARGSHEE
T
109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE
73 TO
80/140

86,87/49
106
TO 109/53

112,113/79
128 /84
129 /85
173 TO 1/117
175/92
179 TO 54/108 2 ,4 /118
E .O 182/93 17,18/12 Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan
48/304 184,185,186 75 ,76 1 ST DAY IN 17/121 8 70 TO writtent this mail and not present in
EXH :65(1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 63/374 /95 /111 THANE PLANT 131/669 20/122
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 80/140 enquiry
KARDILE W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

E.O P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB QUEST NO/
REPORT Chargsheet KARDILE Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE PAG NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT

106,107,108
/54
8/ 225 112,113,114 NOT IN NOT IN 17,18/130
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 36/284 /81
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ. SERVICE SERVICE 70/142

106,107,108
/54 51,52,53/
37/286 112,113,115 109 NOT IN 17,18/130
2 27.06.2013 P Y P 38/287 /81,82 75,76/113 SERVICE 70/142

106,107,108
/54 51,52,53/
E.O 3 15.07.2013 UO Y P 39/288 112,113,115
132/670 /81,82
109
75,76/113
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/130
70/142

106,107,108
/54 51,52,53/
4 23.07.2013 P Y P 40/290
112,113,116
/81,82
109
75,76/113
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/130
70/142

106,107,108
/54 51,52,53/
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291
112,113,118
/81,82
109
75,76/113
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/130
70/142
106,107,108 17,18/130
/54 70/142
42/292 112,113,119 51,52,53/ 31/131 70
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 43/293
44/294
/81,82
186/98
109
75,76/113
NOT IN
SERVICE
to
80/142,143

NOT IN 70 to
7 08.02.2014 WO NO WO 42/292 120/83 SERVICE 80/142,143

E.O 8 14.03.2014 P Y A 45/296

132/670 121/83
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/130
7/142

P A 46/298
E.O H.O 9 24.03.2014 (Thane) Y 67/380 122/83
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/130
7/142

MITING IN 2.30 PM
IN H.O( W-
MANOJ )NOT 124,125/83

51 ,52 ,53
/109 17,18/130
54/110 70 to
74/142 75
51/42 51 , 54 , 75 ,76 NOT IN 16/6/2014 to 80/143
10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014 123/83 58 ,61 62 /113 SERVICE JOINING 132/670 31/131

51,52,53/
173 to 109
E.O i 22.04.2014 PL Y A 178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 51/351
75,76/113
67/112
17,18/130
70/142
51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P 178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 54/355
75,76/113
68/112
17,18/130
70/142

51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E.O iii 26.05.2014 UO Y A 178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 58/362
75,76/113
69/112
17,18/130
70/142

51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E.O iv 24.02.2014 P Y A 178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 61/370
75,76/113
70/112
17,18/130
70/142

51/42
179/96
180,181/97
123/83 173 51,52,53/
to 109
E.O v 28.05.2014 UO Y A 178/95,96
112,114/81
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 62/371
75,76/113
71/112
17,18/130
70/142

59/368
67/380 51/42 59/368 ,67/ 51,52,53/
11/231 179/96 380 ,11/231 109 11/231 ,12
H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO Y A 12/233
19/241
180,181/97
124/83
,12/233 ,19/ 54/110
241 71/112
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
/233 ,19/2 17,18/130
41 70/142

51,52,53/
12
E.O P.KANITKAR 16.07.2014 P P.Y ABSENT
59/368
132/670 125/83,84
109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ
70,71,72/1
42
51,52,53/
12-A
EXH 59/132 S.KUMAR 16.07.2014 P P.Y 132/670
109
54/110
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
73 TO
80/142.143

NO CHARG
IN 51,52,53/
13 17.07.2014 P NO A CHARGSHEE
T
109
54/110
NOT IN
SERVICE

86,87/50
106
TO
109/54 /53

112,113/81
128 /86
129 /87
173 TO 1/117
175/95
179 TO 54/110 2 ,4 /118
E .O 182/96,97 17,18/130
48/304 184,185,186 75 ,76 1 ST DAY IN 17/121 70 TO
EXH :65(1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 63/374 /98 /113 THANE PLANT 131/669 20/122
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 80/142,143
Particular

Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who

is witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh

Morkar was on 3 rd Shift

Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar

weekly off

Morkar weekly off

1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off.
2. Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent
by Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry

All AW weekly off Saturday

This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty

not produce in enquiry

This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and

meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
( jogeshwari) incident .
Morkar is in II shift and also present in
thane.

MMU present in thane plant.

ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi

Nadkarni and Sawargaonkar are witnessess
and not present in enquiry.

JUNE 2013 TO JUN 2014

Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not

produce Presenty
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is
witness and not present in enquiry.

Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile

is Union off and Kardiles name mentioned
in mail

Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our

names are not mentioned.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty

mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not

present in enquiry

incident happened with technicial director

and Senior director HR and both are not
present in enquiry

finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

Kanitakr are saying that this incident
happened with them in their cabin and
Kanitakar sitting in Thane as well as Suman
sitting in Ho
Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same
incident he and Kanitakr telling happened
with them.

NO CHARG IN CHARGSHEET

Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan

writtent this mail and not present in
enquiry
MORKAR W-1 w-2 W-3 W-4

EXHIBIT Suman EXHIBIT

E.O P.V.KANITKAR /pag no P. Shenoy EXHIBIT QUEST BAIG EXHIBIT QUEST Kumar /pag no QUEST
(Director plant PARAB QUEST NO/ AST.MAG. /pag no NO/ PAG (Security /pag no NO/ (Director PARAB NO/ PAG
REPORT Chargsheet MORKAR Guilty operation) FILE PAG NO PLANT SERVICE PARAB FILE NO Consultant) PARAB FILE PAG NO operations) FILE NO

Points Dates PRESENT Y/N PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT PRESENT Particular

106,107,108
/52
1 15.03.2013 P Y P 8/ 225
36/284
112,113,114
/79
PRESENTY IS NOT
PRODUCE IN ENQ.
NOT IN
SERVICE
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126 Madhav Sawargaonkar (Plant Personel) who
70/138 is witness was not present in enq.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his presenty

106,107,108 51 ,52 ,53,

/52 54/105,10
112,113/79 6
2 27.06.2013 P3 NO P 37/286
38/287
115
MISSING
75 ,76
/109
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138
Yogesh Tawde Union off and Munjesh
Morkar was on 3 rd Shift

106,107,108 51 ,52 ,53,

/52 54/105,10
112,113/79 6
3 15.07.2013 WO NO P 39/288 116
132/670 MISSING
75 ,76
/109
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138
Rajendra Kardile Union off and Morkar
weekly off

106,107,108 51 ,52 ,53,

/52 54/105,10
112,113/79 6
4 23.07.2013 WO NO P 40/290
117
MISSING
75 ,76
/109
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138 Morkar weekly off

106,107,108 51 ,52 ,53,

/52 54/105,10
112,113/79 6
5 05.02.2014 P Y P 41/291
118
MISSING
75 ,76
/109
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138
106,107,108 51 ,52 ,53,
/52 54/105,10
42/292 112,113/79 6 1.Saturday 08.02.2014 all are on weekly off.
6 7.02.2014 P Y P 43/293
44/294
119
MISSING
75 ,76
/109
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138
2. Exh. No.43 Dated 07.02.2014 Mail sent
by Mr.Badhe and not present in enquiry

E.O 7 08.02.2014 P Y WO 42/292 120/80

NOT IN
SERVICE
70 TO
80/138 All AW weekly off Saturday

8 14.03.2014 WO NO A 45/296
132/670 121/80
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138
This mail sent by Shenoy and his presenty
not produce in enquiry

This mail written by Kanitkar at 9.52 am and

46/298
MAIL 9.50 AM H.O 9 24.03.2014 P2 NO A 67/380 122/80
NOT IN
SERVICE
17,18/126
70/138
meeting held on 2.30 pm and this is HO
( jogeshwari) incident .
Morkar is in II shift and also present in
thane.

MMU present in thane plant.

MITING IN 2.30 PM ManoJ Arora, Vivek Dhariwal, Lakshmi

IN H.O( W- Nadkarni and Sawargaonkar are witnessess
MANOJ )NOT and not present in enquiry.
51 ,52 ,53
/105
54/107 17,18/126
70 TO
51/40 ,123 51 , 54 , 75 ,76 NOT IN 16/6/2014 73/138 74
10 Jun 2013 to Jun 2014 /80 58 ,61 62 /109 SERVICE JOINING 132/670 TO 80/139

17,18/126
173 to 51 ,53 70 to
E.O i 22.04.2014 P Y A 178/91,92
112,114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
PRODUES IN ENQ 51/351
/106
67/108
80/138
31/129
Only Morkar Towel Problem. Shenoy not
produce Presenty
51/40,
179/92,
180,181/93
123/80 173
to 17,18/126
178/91,92 51 ,53 70 to
E.O ii 02.05.2014 UO Y P 112 to
114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 54/355
/106
68/108
80/138
31/129
Shenoy not produce Presenty. Naik is
witness and not present in enquiry.

51/40,
179/92,
180,181/93
123/80 173
to 17,18/126
178/91,92 51 ,53 70 to Shenoy not produce Presenty. Only Kardile
E.O iii 26.05.2014 PL Y A 112 to
114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 58/362
/106
68/108
80/138
31/129
is Union off and Kardiles name mentioned
in mail

51/40,
179/92,
180,181/93
123/80 173
to 17,18/126
178/91,92 51 ,53 70 to
E.O iv 24.02.2014 P Y A 112 to
114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 61/370
/106
68/108
80/138
31/129
Santosh Sawant Committee Meeting our
names are not mentioned.

Pradeep Shenoy not produce his Presenty

51/40,
179/92,
180,181/93
123/80 173
to 17,18/126
178/91,92 51 ,53 70 to
E .O v 28.05.2014 UO Y A 112 to
114/79
PRESENTI SHEET NOT IN
PRODUES ON ENQ 62/371
/106
68/108
80/138
31/129
mail dated 28.05.2014 Mr.Badhe and not
present in enquiry
59/368
67/380 59/368 ,67/
11/231 380 ,11/231 51 ,53 11/231 ,12 incident happened with technicial director
H.O 11 04.07.2014 UO NO A 12/233
19/241 124/80
,12/233 ,19/
241
/105
68/108
NOT IN
SERVICE ****
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
/233 ,19/2
41
70 to
72/138
and Senior director HR and both are not
present in enquiry

finding page no.97. Both Suman Kumar and

Kanitakr are saying that this incident
12 happened with them in their cabin and
E.O
P.KANITKA
R 16.07.2014 P Y ABSENT
59/368
132/670 125/81
NOT IN
SERVICE
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
Kanitakar sitting in Thane as well as Suman
sitting in Ho

73 to Suman Kumar was sitting in HO and same

12-A
EXH 59/132 S.KUMAR 16.07.2014 P Y 132/670
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
80/138,13 incident he and Kanitakr telling happened
9 with them.

73 to
13 17.07.2014 P Y A NOT IN
SERVICE
80/138,13
9

86,87/48
106 to
109 /52
112,113/78
128 /83
129 /84
173 174 1/115
175/91 179 2 ,4
to 54/106 /116 17,18/126
E .O 182/92,93 70 to Kotwal and Shakeel ahemad unnikrishnan
EXH :65(1) 14 01.08.2014 P Y 48/304
63/374
184 to
186/94
75 ,76
/109
1 ST DAY IN
THANE PLANT 131/669
17/119
20/119
PRESENTI SHEET NOT
IN PRODUES ON ENQ
73/138 74
to 80/139
writtent this mail and not present in
enquiry