Supercharger VS Turbocharger
Supercharger VS Turbocharger
VS
TURBOCHARGER
VOLUMETRIC EFFICIENCY
Advantages: Disadvantages:
But, we can not simply pump more fuel into an engine. The chemically correct
mixture ( 14 : 1 :: Air : Fuel ) – is an essential for an engine to operate perfectly.
1 Roots Types
2 Centrifugal Types
3 Screw Types
ROOTS SUPERCHARGER
Mechanical :
Belt
Gear Drive
Chain Drive
Other :
Electric motor
Advantages :
Increased Power
No lag – Consistent power delivery
Generally better throttle response
No special procedures or extra maintenance
Easier to install than turbochargers
disadvantages :
Consume a lot of power from the engine (therefore, not very efficient)
Increases the strain on the engine
Expensive
Noise
TURBOCHARGER
The major disadvantage of a supercharger is it takes some of the engine power to drive the unit .
In some installations, as much as 20% of the engine power is used by a mechanical supercharger.
A turbocharger uses the eat of the exhaust to power a turbine wheel and therefore does not
directly reduce the engine power.
A turbocharger is an exhaust-driven air pump consisting of a pair of turbine wheels, not unlike
pinwheels, on a single shaft. One turbine is positioned in the exhaust stream; when the engine
revs, the exhaust makes it spin. This turns the second turbine, which is part of the intake system
that directs air into the engine, and acts as a pump.
In order to develop boost, the engine must be working hard enough to produce significant
exhaust pressure to spin the turbocharger. This results in “turbo lag” — the engine does not get a
power boost at lower engine speeds, and it feels as if the car is hesitating instead of accelerating.
Newer, more technologically advanced cars have less turbo lag than older cars. The advantage to
using turbocharging to boost power is that when the turbo is active, the engine uses fuel,
whether it be gasoline or diesel.
PARTS OF A TURBOCHARGER
HOW A TURBOCHARGER WORKS
Wastegate
A turbocharger uses exhaust gasses to increase
boost, which causes the engine to make more
exhaust gases, which in turn increases the boost
from the turbocharger.
To prevent over boost and severe engine
damage, most turbo systems uses wastegate.
A wastegate is a valve similar to a door that can
be open and close.
The wastegate is a bypass valve at the exhaust
inlet to the turbine.
It allows all the exhaust into the turbine, or it
can route part of the exhaust past the turbine to
the exhaust system
TURBOCHARGER FAILURES
MAINTENANCE / PROBLEMS
Lack of oil
Dirty oil
Mechanical damage of vane wheels
Wastegate control problems
Oil caking
TURBOCHARGER
OR
SUPERCHARGER?