The Concept of Human Being
The Concept of Human Being
of Human
Being
Activity!
Go to your respective group
and create a chart about the
ideas of different philosophers
from different periods
regarding the concept of
human person.
Answer the following questions:
1. What is the concept of Plato about the
human person?
2. How we are going to simplify
Aristotle’s matter and form as a concept of
human person.
3. In holistic view, how does Descartes
explain the human person?
ANALYZE THIS
State ANALOGY
Individual Function Virtue
SPIRITEDNESS
APPETITES
The division was a result of a
conversation in Plato’s The Republic
, where the characters that the ideal
society is made up of three types of
citizens.
The three types of citizens:
workers
soldiers
rulers
The idea here is that the
society is simply an
enlarged person
The rulers’
counterpart in the
human body is the
head, which
symbolizes the
reasoning part.
The soldiers’
counterpart is the
chest, which
symbolizes the
spirited part.
The workers’
counterpart is the
stomach, which
symbolizes the
appetitive part.
These parts and their functions
have their corresponding
virtues:
wisdom for reasoning, courage
for spiritedness, and moderation
for appetites.
ARISTOTLE
ARISTOTLE
- Plato’s most famous
student.
There are lot of differences in
their philosophies, one which is
how they looked at human
beings.
Its how the soul is related to the
body that Aristotle differs from
Plato. Aristotle considers things
as composed of two co-
principles.
Two co-principles
MATTER FORM
Is the principle
which actualizes FORM
a thing and
makes a thing
what it is.
It is viewed as
the potentiality Matter
to receive the
form.
In short, FORM
is viewed as Matter &
FORM
ACT while
matter is viewed
as POTENCY.
Example:
a piece of paper has matter
and form.
If we burn the paper, it
will turn into a ash
because the actual paper
has the potency to become
ashes.
There will never be a moment
when matter or form will exist
independently of each other
because they are only principles
and do not possess existence in
their own.
There will never be a moment
when matter or form will exist
independently of each other
because they are only principles
and do not possess existence in
their own.
This body no longer holds the
form of man, just like the ashes
which formerly hold the form a
paper.
Now we say that the body holds
a new form, that CADAVER.
Cadaver – a dead body: one
intended for dissection
Aristotle then, a human being is
always composite of body and
soul.
DESCARTES
Rene Descartes
- French philosopher
- widened the gap between the body
and soul even more as he sets out to
prove that the only thing in this world
which cannot be doubted is the
existence of the thinking self.
Rene Descartes
- he argues for the real distinction
between the body and soul.
- he began with doubting everything
that had previously been considered as
knowledge.
Claiming that the senses are the
sources of previously established
knowledge, and that senses are not
reliable, Descartes argued that we
should doubt everything that is
delivered to us by our senses.
He may doubt his bodily existence
because he can deceived by his
senses. But he cannot doubt his
thinking because his thinking
requires a subject – the thinker.
He establishes his own reality with
the famous line
“I think, therefore, I am”
the subject “I” however, of this
claim does not refer to man or to
rational animal.