Duct PDF
Duct PDF
Acorn Structures/PIX00139
ducts in attics or crawl spaces lose from 25% to 40% of the heat-
ing or cooling energy that passes through them. In an era of
increasing concern for energy efficiency, this is no longer
acceptable.
RT
ME
NT OF
EN
U.S. Department of Energy
Building Technologies Program
A
ER
GY
ICA
U N IT
Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable
ER
ED
ST A
AT E S OF
A common type of home duct system, showing energy flows and losses.
level are also typical. Furthermore, we’ll assume that they leak benchmark, let us assume that in Chicago three-quarters of the
about as much as an average duct system.2 energy requirement of the house is for heating, whereas in
Orlando three-quarters is for cooling. The average duct efficiency
With these parameters, ASHRAE Standard 1523 can be used to will then be 67% in either location. In these typical cases, then,
calculate an expected average efficiency4 of the duct system one-third of the energy given to the ducts is lost before it gets
over an entire heating or cooling season. The results are as to the living space.
follows:
• Chicago house: 63% for heating, 83% for cooling How much better can we do? A reasonable target for a duct
retrofit would be to reduce the leakage by two-thirds—to 5%
• Orlando house: 74% for heating, 65% for cooling.
of the system fan flow on each side of the duct system—and
Even within a given climate region, different homes and lifestyles increase the insulation level to R-8. This would result in the
will have different ratios of heating to cooling. However, as a following duct efficiency levels:
_____________ • Chicago house: 81% for heating, 90% for cooling
2This assumes that the ducts are insulated to R-4 and have 15% leakage on each side
• Orlando house: 86% for heating, 82% for cooling.
(supply and return). This leakage level may sound high, but it is a couple of percent less
than what was found in a recent national laboratory study.
3ASHRAE Standard 152 is a nationally standardized method for measuring duct efficiency, Using the same assumptions as above, this results in an average
developed by the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning duct efficiency of 83% in either location.
Engineers, Inc.
4Duct efficiency (more precisely, “thermal distribution efficiency”) is calculated as the ratio With the original ducts, the equipment must provide 150 units of
of (a) the fuel energy that would be needed by the system if it had perfect, loss-free ducts comfort in order to deliver 100 units of heating or cooling comfort
to (b) the fuel energy needed by the actual system with the as-found ducts. This definition
accounts for system interactions. to the house, because only two-thirds (67%) of that comfort makes
2 Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable
it to the living space. With the repaired ducts, the equipment only • original duct leakage less than the benchmark
needs to provide 120 units of comfort heating or cooling to get • leakage predominantly in the return ducts
100 units (83% of 120) into the house. Thus, the load on the
• original ducts insulated more than R-4.
equipment is reduced by 30 units, which is 20% of the original
requirement. The cost of running the equipment also will be System Interactions
reduced by 20% over a heating or cooling season.
Duct energy losses and equipment inefficiencies can work
together to give surprisingly low overall system efficiency.
Warren Gretz/PIX03072
When a furnace meeting the current national standards (78%
Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency) is combined with a typical duct
system installed in a vented attic or open crawlspace (60%–75%
seasonal efficiency), only about half the heating value of the fuel
will make it into the house!
When placed in a home’s conditioned space, ducts can easily blend into the décor.
3
the duct walls themselves. These benefits can soften the energy more time in the ducts and can, therefore, cool down more before
penalty of the losses because some of the lost heat is, in effect, it is delivered to the living space. The lesson here is that if you are
recovered. This is called thermal regain. going to use premium equipment, you should also have premium
ducts.
Locations with the highest thermal regain are the best places to
install ducts. When located within the conditioned space, ducts Pressure Effects — When in operation, the central air-handler
have 100% regain because the lost heat is used. Unvented, unin- fan often changes the distribution of pressures within the house.
sulated basements and crawl spaces have intermediate merit Thus, for example, a bedroom could have pressure higher than
as locations for ducts, because about half the heating or cooling the living room. These pressure changes may affect the rate at
value of thermal loss is regained. Other duct locations, such as which outdoor air infiltrates into the home, usually increasing the
vented crawl spaces, attics, and exterior walls have regain factors heating or cooling load.
ranging from 30% down to essentially zero and should be avoided
Health, Safety, and Comfort Issues in Residential
if possible. Ducts
Equipment Efficiency — Some types of equipment, such as heat Pressure changes caused by the air-handler fan can affect the
pumps and variable-capacity air conditioners, might suffer a loss health of the home’s occupants through the unintended distri-
of efficiency because of a poorly performing duct system, and this bution of indoor air pollution. Room pressures can also be influ-
penalty is added to the energy losses in the duct system. Installing enced by the various exhaust fans in the house (bathroom fans,
a variable-capacity furnace in a poorly insulated duct system can vented range hoods, clothes dryers). Therefore, be sure to con-
cause an already mediocre duct efficiency to drop off even further. sider the combined operation of all air movers in the house when
Because the furnace is running at low capacity, heated air spends assessing the potential for health and safety problems.
4 Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable
The most common health problems associated with ducts arise
5
From the point of view of the heating, ventilation, and air-condi-
6 Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable
Step One — Inspect the Duct System pressure is a measure of the extent of leakage in the ducts. Varia-
Evaluating a duct system’s efficiency begins with visual inspec- tions on this technique can obtain more detailed information, such
tion. Here are some things to check for: as, which side of the duct system (supply or return) leaks more
and how much of the leakage is to the outside.
• disconnected ducts near registers and where runouts connect
with trunk ducts
Step Three — Measure the System Airflow Rate
• excessive leaking where some part of the building is used as a Measuring airflow rate at the system fan is nearly as important as
duct (panned joists, vertical chases, and the like) measuring duct leakage. The efficiency of the duct system depends
not on duct leakage alone, but on duct leakage as a fraction of fan
• uninsulated ductwork outside the conditioned space. In the case
flow. Another equally important reason is that low fan flow is one
of attic ducts, consider adding R-value even if the ducts are
of the major causes of poor air-conditioner performance. Whatever
insulated.
the problem that caused the original call for help, it will usually
7
Installation and Repair of Duct Systems
Charlie Castillega/PIX09808
When making duct repairs, the contractor has to work with the
materials at hand. Fortunately, the state of the art in duct repair
is advancing rapidly.
“Is it OK to use duct tape?” That’s one of the first questions asked
in a duct repair class. The answer is simple: “A duct repair should
last as long as the ducts themselves.” Consequently, that rules out
most types of duct tape that one can normally purchase for duct
sealing.
It’s free, it’s fun (at least for anyone who likes to play with num- When repairing ducts, plan the job. Remember that the tasks of
bers), and it can quickly show the effects of duct location, air sealing and insulating the ducts are equally important. A well-
leakage, and insulation level on duct efficiency. planned job will include the following steps:
8 Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable
• sketch the duct system
9
practitioners should keep abreast of new technologies of auto- References, Resources, and Additional Information
matic duct sealing. One of these methods makes use of aerosol
This brochure has been condensed from a larger publication. See
sealants blown into the duct with a computer-controlled
page 1 of this brochure for information on how to get a copy. The
adjustable-speed fan.
following references may also be useful:
10 Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable
Energy Efficient Design of New Low-Rise Residential Buildings. Residential Field Testing of an Aerosol-Based Technology for Seal-
Standard 90.2-1993. American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, ing Ductwork, by M. P. Modera, D. Dickerhoff, and O. Nilssen.
and Air-Conditioning Engineers, 1791 Tullie Circle, N.E., Atlanta, Proceedings of the 1996 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Effi-
Georgia 30329. ciency in Buildings. Vol. 1, pp. 169–176.
Stopping Duct Quacks: Longevity of Residential Duct Sealants, by
Residential Design Manuals
M. Sherman, I. Walker, and D. Dickerhoff. Proceedings of the 2000
Manual J: Residential Load Calculation
ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings. Vol. 1,
Manual S: Residential Equipment Selection pp. 273–284.
Manual D: Residential Duct Systems
Web Links
Air Conditioning Contractors of America, 2800 Shirlington Road, Home Energy Magazine
Suite 300, Arlington, Virginia 22206. www.homeenergy.org/
11
A Strong Energy Portfolio
for a Strong America
Energy efficiency and clean, renewable
energy will mean a stronger economy,
a cleaner environment, and greater
energy independence for America.
Working with a wide array of state,
community, industry, and university
partners, the U.S. Department of
Energy’s Office of Energy Efficiency
and Renewable Energy invests in a
diverse portfolio of energy technologies.
Produced for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, a DOE national laboratory.
An electronic copy of this factsheet is
available on the Building America Web November 2004 • DOE/GO-102004-1606
site at www.buildingamerica.gov Printed with a renewable-source ink on paper containing at least 50% wastepaper, including 20% postconsumer waste.
12 Bringing you a prosperous future where energy is clean, abundant, reliable, and affordable